Triple-I Logo

Texas Insurance Affordability Struggles Tied to Complex Mix of Cost Drivers

Featured Image
SPONSORED BY
November 16, 2026

By Lewis Nibbelin, Research Writer, Triple-I

Texas insurance costs rank among the least affordable in the nation for residents and businesses alike. A new Triple-I Issues Brief discusses the drivers of this trend and cautions state legislators to make sure any attempts to rein in rising costs target their underlying causes.

According to Triple-I’s Insurance Affordability Index, Texans spend about 4.1% of median income on their home insurance premiums. Approximately 1.9% is spent on personal auto insurance premiums, placing Texas among the 10 most affordability-challenged states by both metrics.

Commercial lines are also feeling the pressure. In 2025, the direct incurred loss and defense and cost containment (DCC) ratio for Texas commercial auto insurance was third highest in the United States, at 86.6% versus 73.6% nationally. General liability ranked sixth at 86.3%, compared to the national ratio of 78.7%.

Legal system abuse plays a substantial role in increasing the cost of resolving claims, ultimately raising the insurance premiums residents and businesses pay. Nuclear verdicts alone raise Texas property/casualty insurance costs by at least 15.25%, leading to an $8.8 billion loss in the state’s annual total spending, based on analysis from The Perryman Group. Research from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s Institute for Legal Reform found excessive litigation costs the average Texas household about $4,594 annually.

Severe weather adds to the strain, with damage caused by climate-related perils accounting for the greatest share of insured homeowners’ losses in the state. Texas remains especially vulnerable to convective storms, often ranking first in the country for both tornadoes and hailstorms.

Model what’s working

As policymakers seek ways to address these influences, it’s important to learn from states that are succeeding. Florida, for instance, has attracted more than 20 new carriers to its residential market since enacting reforms in 2022 and 2023 to curb litigation abuse and fraud. During that time, the market share of Citizens Property Insurance Corp., the state-run insurer of last resort, fell from 15% to 2%.

Programs to reduce severe weather exposure are also essential to moderating insurance costs. Strengthen Alabama Homes – which offers state residents grants for roofs built to the IBHS FORTIFIED™ standard for severe weather mitigation – have demonstrated success in reducing post-disaster damage and claims, prompting many states to adopt their own programs.

A similar initiative will be piloted in Dallas in early 2027 by a new national nonprofit coalition, Resilient Home America (RHA). RHA will help families protect their homes by providing grants and loans for roof replacements built to the same IBHS standard. Bringing together insurers, lenders, builders, community leaders, government partners, and other nonprofits like Triple-I, the coalition plans to scale and replicate the Dallas project in communities nationwide.

Learn More:

Lessons for Texas from Florida’s Legal System Reforms

New Triple-I Campaign Highlights Consumer Cost of Legal System Abuse

Third-Party Litigation Funding Reform Advances in Over 20 States

Rising Litigation Adds Pressure to Auto Liability Costs

Florida Reforms Drive Benefits for Consumers

Storm-Resistant Roof Efforts Gain Ground

Related

View All
Arrow Right