Commercial Insurance

Directors And Officers Liability Insurance

Directors and officers liability insurance (D&O) covers directors and officers of a company for negligent acts or omissions and for misleading statements that result in suits against the company. There are various forms of D&O coverage. Corporate reimbursement coverage indemnifies directors and officers of the organization. Side-A coverage provides D&O coverage for personal liability when directors and officers are not indemnified by the firm. Entity coverage for claims made specifically against the company is also available. D&O policies may be broadened to include coverage for employment practices liability (EPL). EPL coverage may also be purchased as a stand-alone policy.

Sixty-nine percent of corporations purchased D&O coverage in 2017, according to the 2018 RIMS Benchmark Survey from the Risk and Insurance Management Society and Advisen, based on a survey of 511 organizations. Banks and materials companies were the most likely to purchase D&O coverage in 2017, with 85 percent of respondents in both industries purchasing the coverage, followed by 84 percent of respondents in the education industry. According to Advisen, the new cases count that may be covered by D&O coverage fell in 2017 compared with 2016. Total shareholder risks, an area that encompasses securities class action suits, merger objections, derivative shareholder suits and other suits brought by shareholders, has stayed at relatively constant levels over the past four years. However, in 2017 alone the number of merger objection cases rose 28 percent from 2016 and securities class action suits rose about 6 percent, while the number of derivative shareholder suits fell by 16 percent.

AIG led the top 10 writers of D&O liability insurance in 2017 with $940 million in direct premiums written and 15 percent of the market, followed by Chubb Ltd. with 12 percent and AXA with 10 percent.

Types Of Directors And Officers Liability Claims By Ownership, 2011-2014 (1)

(1) Based on participants in the survey that reported one or more claims over the five-year period.

Source: JLT Specialty 2015 U.S. Directors and Officers Liability Survey.

View Archived Graphs

Terrorism Insurance/TRIA

In addition to the risk of natural disasters, the insurance industry faces the threat of terrorist attacks. Losses stemming from the destruction of the World Trade Center and other buildings by terrorists on September 11, 2001 totaled about $32.5 billion, including commercial liability and group life insurance claims -- not adjusted for inflation -- or $35.9 billion in 2005 dollars. About two thirds of these losses were paid for by reinsurers, companies that provide insurance for insurers.

Prior to September 11, insurers provided terrorism coverage to their commercial insurance customers essentially free of charge because the chance of property damage from terrorist acts was considered remote. After September 11, insurers began to reassess the risk. For a while terrorism coverage was scarce. Reinsurers were unwilling to reinsure policies in urban areas perceived to be vulnerable to attack. Primary insurers filed requests with their state insurance departments for permission to exclude terrorism coverage from their commercial policies.

Concerned about the limited availability of terrorism coverage in high risk areas and its impact on the economy, Congress passed the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act (TRIA). The Act provides a temporary program that, in the event of major terrorist attack, allows the insurance industry and federal government to share losses according to a specific formula. TRIA was signed into law on November 26, 2002.and renewed again for two years in December 2005.  Passage of TRIA enabled a market for terrorism insurance to begin to develop because the federal backstop effectively limits insurers’ losses, greatly simplifying the underwriting process. TRIA was extended for another seven years to 2014 in December 2007. The new law is known as the Terrorism Risk Insurance Program Reauthorization Act (TRIPRA) of 2007.

See Background on: Terrorism risk and insurance for further information 

Employment Practices Liability

Employment practices liability insurance provides protection for an employer against claims made by employees, former employees or potential employees. It covers discrimination (age, sex, race, disability, etc.), wrongful termination of employment, sexual harassment and other employment-related allegations and lawsuits.

Discrimination and wrongful employee dismissal or termination were the most frequently cited employment-related claims in the 2004 Tillinghast survey of more than 2,400 U.S. and Canadian corporations.

The chart below shows trends in jury awards in employment practices liability cases.

Trends In Employment Practices Liability, 2012-2016

 

Year Median (midpoint) award Probability range (1)
2012 $69,672 $12,197 - $259,380
2013 100,000 15,707 - 251,623
2014 86,250 20,000 - 302,574
2015 81,239 17,566 - 336,245
2016 123,447 25,045 - 450,000

(1) The middle 50 percent of all awards arranged in ascending order in a sampling, 25 percent above and below the median award.

Source: Reprinted with permission of Thomson Reuters, Employment Practice Liability: Jury Award Trends and Statistics, 2017 edition.

View Archived Tables

Excess Casualty

Excess casualty insurance, also known as excess liability insurance, which provides protection from infrequent catastrophic accidents or occurrences, is similar to umbrella liability coverage, which also increases the liability protection provided by a company’s insurance policies.  The main difference between excess and umbrella policies is that umbrella policies cover all underlying liability policies, whereas excess casualty policies increase the limits of liability on one particular policy.  Both types of policies are designed to cover large, infrequent losses such as injuries caused by the collapse of a department store roof under the weight of a category 5 hurricane.

Each year the broker Marsh reviews the excess liability insurance-buying decisions of more than 4,000 organizations worldwide, including some 2,800 U.S. companies. The chart below indicates the percentage of U.S. firms experiencing a loss of $5 million or more. Those that experienced such a loss tended to purchase much higher limits of liability coverage.

U.S. Firms experiencing a loss of $5 million or more, 2004-2008 (1)

(Percent)

 

(1) Loss experience in the past 5 years.

Source: 2008 Limits of Liability Report, © Marsh Inc. 2008.

Other Specialty Lines

There are a wide variety of insurance policies that cover special risks not insured under the more common forms of commercial insurance. “The Insurance Marketplace,” a directory of specialty providers produced each year by Rough Notes, listed over 600 specialty coverages, ranging from acupuncture specialists liability to kidnap/ransom insurance to special events liability in its latest directory.

Top 25 U.S Surplus Lines Groups By Direct Premiums Written, 2017

($000)

Rank Group Direct premiums written Percent of total U.S. surplus lines market
1 Lloyd's $10,325,000 23.0%
2 American International Group (1) 3,239,996 7.2
3 Markel Corporation Group 2,167,568 4.8
4 Nationwide Group 1,737,150 3.9
5 W. R. Berkley Insurance Group 1,698,541 3.8
6 Berkshire Hathaway Ins. Group 1,503,234 3.3
7 Chubb INA Group 1,445,248 3.2
8 Fairfax Financial (USA) Group 1,305,476 2.9
9 Liberty Mutual Insurance Companies 1,288,834 2.9
10 XL Catlin America Group 1,142,292 2.5
11 Zurich Financial Services Group NA  1,135,953 2.5
12 Alleghany Insurance Holdings Group 790,305 1.8
13 Argo Group 723,869 1.6
14 Tokio Marine U.S. PC Group 688,481 1.5
15 AXIS U.S. Operations 681,015 1.5
16 Sompo Holdings U.S. Group 671,194 1.5
17 QBE Americas Group 642,289 1.4
18 Great American P & C Group 600,356 1.3
19 CNA Insurance Companies 568,441 1.3
20 Aspen U.S. Insurance Group 539,155 1.2
21 James River Group 530,077 1.2
22 Swiss Reinsurance Group 485,098 1.1
23 Arch Insurance Group 469,965 1.0
24 Starr International Group 425,901 0.9
25 Navigators Insurance Group 411,553 0.9
  Total, top 25 $35,216,991 78.5%
  Total U.S. surplus lines market $44,878,931 100.0%

(1) Does not include direct surplus lines premium moved to offshore affiliate AIG Europe, Ltd.

Source: A.M. Best data and research.

View Archived Tables